Which Horseshoe Brands Deliver The Best Quality? A Comprehensive Review
When it comes to horseshoe pitching—whether for backyard fun or high-level competition—the quality of your gear can make a huge difference. A well-balanced, durable horseshoe offers more than just better accuracy and feel. It helps you throw with confidence, play consistently, and enjoy the game more overall.
But not all horseshoe brands are created equal.
With so many options available today—ranging from inexpensive recreational sets to professional-grade gear—it can be difficult to know which brands truly deliver on performance, durability, and value. That’s where this guide comes in.
In this comprehensive review, we break down the top horseshoe brands based on quality, reputation, design features, and user experience. Whether you’re a beginner or a serious competitor, you’ll find recommendations tailored to your skill level and goals.
Why Brand Quality Matters in Horseshoe Pitching
Choosing the right brand isn’t about paying for a name—it’s about choosing a product you can trust. Here’s what a top-tier brand typically offers:
- NHPA-approved equipment for regulation play
- Consistent weight and balance across sets
- Durable materials that resist wear and tear
- Comfortable grip and performance-enhancing features
- Reputation for customer service and support
Low-quality brands often cut corners with casting, finish, or balance. These flaws may not show up right away, but they quickly reveal themselves during repeated play or competition.
Top Horseshoe Brands Ranked by Quality and Performance
1. St. Pierre Manufacturing
Best For: All skill levels—from backyard players to professionals
Material: Drop-forged steel
Highlights:
- NHPA-approved tournament horseshoes
- Durable powder-coated finishes
- Balanced for turn or flip pitching
- Made in the USA
Top Product Line:
- American Professional Series: A favorite among serious players for its balance, durability, and ringer-friendly design.
Why We Recommend It:
St. Pierre is considered the gold standard by many competitive players. Their products are engineered for both recreational use and sanctioned tournaments, making them a go-to for players looking to step up their game.
2. Gordon Horseshoes
Best For: Competitive players seeking custom-fit performance
Material: Alloy steel and drop-forged steel
Highlights:
- NHPA-approved
- Precision-weighted designs
- Designed by Hall of Fame pitcher Gordon “Gordy” Gronowski
- Available in different weight distributions for personalized fit
Top Product Line:
- Gordon Pro Flip & Gordon Turn: Designed for specialized throwing techniques and available in a variety of custom configurations.
Why We Recommend It:
Gordon Horseshoes are made by players, for players. With customization options and precision balance, these are ideal for anyone serious about league or tournament play.
3. M&M Horseshoes
Best For: League players and professionals
Material: High-quality forged steel
Highlights:
- NHPA-approved for tournament play
- Symmetrical designs for balanced turn or flip styles
- Made in the USA
Top Product Line:
- M&M Mustang and Maverick: Known for their solid feel and outstanding sticking power.
Why We Recommend It:
M&M horseshoes are highly regarded in the competitive community for their craftsmanship and feel. The Mustang model in particular is a favorite for its smooth rotation and reliable landings.
4. Thoroughbred Horseshoes
Best For: Players upgrading from recreational to competitive play
Material: Drop-forged steel
Highlights:
- NHPA-approved
- Innovative ringer break and toe cleat design
- Balanced weight distribution for flip or turn
Top Product Line:
- Thoroughbred Horseshoes: Offers a blend of performance, affordability, and pro-level features.
Why We Recommend It:
Thoroughbred is gaining popularity for producing professional-quality shoes at a more approachable price. Great for experienced players making the leap into competitive leagues.
5. Franklin Sports
Best For: Recreational and beginner players
Material: Cast iron and steel
Highlights:
- Budget-friendly pricing
- Ideal for backyard play
- Available at major retailers
Top Product Line:
- Franklin Recreational Series: Basic horseshoe sets with carrying case and stakes.
Why We Recommend It:
Franklin is a good starting point for casual players. While not NHPA-certified or ideal for long-term competitive use, they’re fine for occasional games with friends and family.
6. Champion Sports
Best For: Children, families, and casual use
Material: Rubber and plastic composite
Highlights:
- Lightweight and safe
- Colorful, kid-friendly designs
- Includes indoor/outdoor play options
Top Product Line:
Why We Recommend It:
These are perfect for schools, seniors, or family events where safety is a priority. Not suitable for serious play, but a great introduction to the game.
Comparing Brands by Key Factors
🏆 Best for Professionals:
St. Pierre, Gordon, and M&M all offer NHPA-certified horseshoes engineered for tournament accuracy, balance, and durability.
💡 Best for Beginners or Intermediates:
Thoroughbred offers pro-level quality with beginner-friendly pricing.
🏡 Best for Backyard Fun:
Franklin and Champion are great for casual games and teaching kids.
💪 Most Durable:
M&M and Gordon lead in steel integrity and finish longevity.
🧤 Best Grip & Comfort:
St. Pierre and Thoroughbred offer smoother finishes and ergonomic designs.
What to Look For When Choosing a Horseshoe Brand
Before you buy, consider these criteria:
- NHPA Certification: Do you plan to compete in tournaments?
- Throwing Style: Some brands offer turn- or flip-friendly designs.
- Material Quality: Forged steel lasts longer than cast iron or rubber.
- Balance & Weight: Look for consistent feel and rotation.
- Finish: Powder coating helps with grip and rust resistance.
Also, think about who else will be using the gear. Are you playing with kids? Hosting casual backyard games? Competing in a league?
Where to Buy Quality Horseshoes
You can find top horseshoe brands at:
- Manufacturer Websites (e.g., St. Pierre, Gordon, M&M)
- Amazon
- Sporting Goods Stores
- Specialty retailers for NHPA players
- Online marketplaces (Always check for authenticity and reviews)
When purchasing online, verify that you’re getting an official product with proper certification and not a replica or generic substitute.
Final Thoughts: Invest in the Right Brand for Your Game
There’s a reason the top names in horseshoe pitching have been around for decades. They’ve earned their reputation through consistent quality, innovation, and a deep understanding of the game.
Whether you’re just starting out or competing at a high level, choosing the right horseshoe brand is one of the smartest investments you can make. Good gear won’t make you a champion overnight—but it will help you play your best, improve faster, and enjoy every game a lot more.
So… what’s in your gear bag? Is it time to upgrade to a better brand and take your game to the next level?
Hi there, and thanks for stopping by! My name is Larry, and I’m the voice behind PlayingHorseshoes.com I love the game and have been playing since I was a kid. I started this blog because I am passionate about the sport, and with all the technology, I hope the sport don’t die. I plan to do my part to keep it going for me and my brother’s sake. Thanks for stopping by, feel free to subscribe and comment. Thank You!
